Lesson Plan – Class 10 English
Unit 7 – Supplementary: A Dilemma
Author: Silas Weir Mitchell | Genre: Short Story
1. Learning Objectives
The teacher aims to enable the students to:
Understand the story A Dilemma and its central theme.
Develop reading, comprehension and vocabulary skills.
Identify the main characters and understand their thoughts and feelings.
Understand the conflict between greed, fear and human happiness.
Develop logical thinking and problem-solving abilities.
Appreciate the importance of making wise decisions.
Learn about the literary contributions of Silas Weir Mitchell.
2. Learning Outcomes
At the end of the lesson, students will be able to:
Narrate the story in their own words.
Explain the dilemma faced by Tom.
Use new vocabulary in meaningful sentences.
Identify the consequences of excessive greed and fear.
Apply logical thinking while facing difficult situations in daily life.
Understand that wealth alone cannot guarantee happiness.
Make sensible decisions instead of allowing fear and anxiety to control them.
Develop patience, courage and problem-solving skills.
3. Introduction
The teacher introduces the lesson by asking the following questions:
Have you ever faced a difficult situation where you had to make a decision?
What would you do if you found a box full of precious jewels?
Would you open a box if someone warned you that it might explode?
Can money alone make a person happy?
What would you do if you had wealth but could not use it?
Teacher's introduction:
The teacher explains that sometimes life puts us in situations where choosing between two possibilities becomes difficult. Such a confusing situation is called a dilemma. Today, we are going to read an interesting story about a man named Tom, who inherits a box full of precious jewels but faces a frightening problem.
4. Reading and Understanding
Reading activities:
The teacher introduces the author and reads the lesson aloud with proper pronunciation and expression.
Students listen carefully and follow the text.
Students read the lesson paragraph by paragraph.
The teacher explains difficult words, phrases and important incidents.
Students identify the main characters and narrate the events in sequence.
New words and meanings
Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
Ingenious | Clever and inventive |
Mania | An extreme desire or obsession |
Malicious | Intending to harm others |
Queer | Strange or unusual |
Appalled | Shocked or horrified |
Oddity | Strange quality |
Closet | Cupboard |
Incredible | Impossible to believe |
Contrive | To plan or devise something |
Despotic | Tyrannical or oppressive |
Avarice | Extreme greed for wealth |
Jest | A joke |
Vivisection | Surgery on a living organism for experimental purposes |
Additional vocabulary:
Annuity – A fixed sum of money received regularly.
Inheritance – Money or property received from someone who has died.
Heir – A person legally entitled to inherit property.
Dynamite – A powerful explosive material.
Dilemma – A difficult situation requiring a choice between alternatives.
5. Mind Map – A Dilemma
A DILEMMA
1. Uncle Philip
- Rich inventor- Loved precious stones- Hated Tom's mother
2. The Inheritance
- Tom becomes heir- Receives an iron box- Rubies, diamonds and pearls
3. The Danger
- Dynamite inside- Box may explode- Key may trigger explosion
4. Tom's Struggle
- Consults experts- Tries different plans- Lives in fear and anxiety
5. Consequences
Susan breaks their engagement.
Tom loses peace of mind.
He becomes isolated.
He cannot enjoy his inherited wealth.
Central Message
Wealth without peace of mind cannot bring happiness.
6. Consolidation and Presentation
Summary of the lesson
The story A Dilemma is about Tom, a poor clerk who inherits a collection of precious jewels from his wealthy uncle, Philip. Uncle Philip was an ingenious inventor who loved collecting rubies, diamonds and pearls.
Before his death, Uncle Philip tells Tom that the jewels are kept in an iron box. However, he warns him through a letter that the box contains a mechanism connected to dynamite, which will explode when the box is unlocked.
Tom becomes frightened and confused. He tries several ways to open the box safely but fails. He consults Professor Clinch, Dr. Schaff and even his father confessor, but nobody is willing to take the risk.
Tom becomes obsessed with the box. His fear affects his health, happiness, financial condition and relationship with Susan, who eventually breaks their engagement.
Even after two years, Tom remains unable to enjoy his inherited wealth. He finally hides the box, changes his name and occupation, and publishes his story seeking a solution.
The story ends with a challenging question: What would a sensible person do when a box contains both immense wealth and the possibility of death?
Moral / Message:
Money cannot guarantee happiness.
Excessive greed can destroy peace of mind.
Fear and overthinking can affect our lives.
Every problem requires logical thinking and courage.
7. Reinforcement
The teacher reinforces the lesson through the following additional information:
A. About the author
Silas Weir Mitchell (1829–1914)
American neurologist and writer.
Born in Philadelphia.
Studied at the University of Pennsylvania.
Known for scientific and literary works.
Considered a pioneer in neurology.
B. Important characters
Character | Role |
|---|---|
Tom | The narrator and heir |
Uncle Philip | A wealthy inventor and collector of jewels |
Susan | Tom's fiancée |
Professor Clinch | Advises Tom about the box |
Dr. Schaff | Uncle Philip's doctor |
Father confessor | Advises Tom to stop worrying |
C. Important concepts
What is a dilemma? – A difficult situation in which a person has to choose between alternatives.
What is dynamite? – A powerful explosive material.
What is an inheritance? – Property or wealth received from a deceased person.
Why is the story humorous and ironic? – Tom becomes extremely wealthy on paper but remains practically poor because he cannot access his jewels.
D. Real-life connection
The teacher explains that people sometimes worry excessively about uncertain situations. Instead of panicking, we should gather reliable information, consult appropriate experts and make sensible decisions.
8. Evaluation
The teacher evaluates the students' understanding through the following questions.
A. Lower Order Thinking (LOT)
Who was Uncle Philip?
What precious stones did Uncle Philip collect?
What was kept inside the iron box?
B. Middle Order Thinking (MOT)
Why did Uncle Philip warn Tom not to shake or unlock the box?
Why did Tom consult Professor Clinch and Dr. Schaff?
How did the iron box affect Tom's relationship with Susan?
C. Higher Order Thinking (HOT)
If you were Tom, what steps would you take to solve the problem?
Do you think Uncle Philip was right in testing Tom in this manner? Give reasons.
Can a person be considered rich if he possesses enormous wealth but cannot enjoy it? Justify your answer.
9. Remedial Teaching
The teacher provides additional support to slow learners through the following strategies:
Explain the story in simple English with Tamil meanings wherever necessary.
Use pictures of an iron box, key, rubies, pearls and diamonds to explain important events.
Read the lesson slowly, paragraph by paragraph.
Provide a simple character chart to help students remember the characters.
Teach five important new words every day through flashcards.
Encourage students to narrate the story using simple sentences.
Give fill-in-the-blanks and matching exercises.
Ask simple oral questions to build confidence.
Provide a short summary with important points for revision.
Remedial activity: Arrange the following events in the correct order:
Tom consults Professor Clinch.
Uncle Philip dies.
Tom inherits an iron box.
Susan breaks their engagement.
Tom reads the warning letter.
10. Writing
The teacher asks the students to complete the following writing activities.
A. Paragraph writing
Write a paragraph on The Dilemma Faced by Tom in about 100–120 words.
B. Character sketch
Write a character sketch of Uncle Philip.
C. Creative writing
Imagine that you are Tom. Write a diary entry describing your feelings after reading your uncle's warning letter.
D. Vocabulary practice
Make meaningful sentences using the following words:
Ingenious
Malicious
Appalled
Incredible
Avarice
11. Follow-up Activities / Homework
Write the summary of A Dilemma in your own words.
Prepare a flowchart showing the important incidents in the story.
Collect pictures of rubies, diamonds and pearls and prepare a small illustrated vocabulary chart.
Write five sentences explaining how Tom's life changed after receiving the inheritance.
Write an answer to the question: "Is money more important than peace of mind? Why?"
Activity-based assignment:
What Would You Do?
Imagine that you have inherited a mysterious box containing valuable jewels, but you are warned that opening it may be dangerous. Write five steps you would take to handle the situation safely and wisely.
Teaching-Learning Materials (TLM)
Teaching methods: Interactive reading, explanation, discussion, storytelling, brainstorming, group activities and question-answer method.
Expected classroom achievement: Students understand the story, acquire new vocabulary, develop logical reasoning and recognise that peace of mind is more valuable than material wealth.

